IDG Network: Login Register
Public, security experts' e-voting views differ sharply
Experts worry more about errors in e-voting than does the public
News Story by Sharon Machlis
AUGUST 06, 2004
The study, conducted in July and early August, aimed to measure public opinion about electronic voting systems and then compare the results with those of security experts -- both IT pros and hackers.
"The degree of difference was just startling," said Larry Ponemon, adjunct professor of ethics and privacy at Carnegie Mellon University and director of the independent institute bearing his name.
The Tucson, Ariz.-based institute collected 2,933 usable responses nationwide from the public, both online and by postal mail, and surveyed 100 attendees at the Black Hat and Defcon hacking/security conferences.
Six out of 10 Black Hat/Defcon attendees had an unfavorable view of e-voting, while only 17% of the public did (22% of experts and 28% of the public were undecided).
Ponemon expected the public to be less concerned about e-voting problems than the hackers. However, in all the studies he has conducted comparing views of experts in various fields with those of the public at large, "I have not really seen differences of this magnitude before," he said.
Twenty percent of the experts cited system and programming errors as their top concern, followed by attempts to influence the outcome of an election (17%). A potential breach of security by hackers and cybercriminals ranked third (15%) as a potential e-voting worry among the Black Hat/Defcon attendees.
Among the public, the top worry was a decline in voter turnout because of fear or distrust of e-voting systems (18%), followed by human errors and privacy violations (15% each).
A number of citizen and political groups as well as security experts have criticized electronic voting systems, charging that they are unreliable and insecure. Many have called for a "paper trail" so that results can be recounted via hard-copy backups. System vendors insist that their machines are reliable and argue that critics are touting unlikely worst-case scenarios as probabilities (see our e-voting special coverage page). The president of the Information Technology Association of America, Harris Miller, told Computerworld that some of the criticism is less about electronic voting machines than "a religious war about open-source software vs. proprietary software" (see story).
In the Ponemon Institute survey, 83% of the experts said e-voting is either less or much less secure against election tampering than traditional paper ballot machines, compared with just 19% of the general public. Almost half (49%) of the experts said electronic voting systems were less likely to record and report their votes accurately, vs. 21% of the public.
"Most people are fairly trusting of this technology," Ponemon said. But among the security experts he spoke with, the feeling was quite different. "They think a lot of this technology is pretty crummy," he said.
GET THE MESSAGE. Excerpt from a new email security book.
Mobilize Your Enterprise For Success New Webcast
Free Guide How to web-enable BPM apps in just weeks, not months
Forrester Webcast Addressing Web App Delivery Challenges
HP workstations at PC prices Xtreme machines for Xtreme users. Click here or Call 1-888-367-2402
Answers to real IT questions. Remedy. Ask a question today.
Remedy. More than just Help Desk, Asset Management, Change Management, and SLA. Remedy. More. Get More from a Free Whitepaper.
Improve IT Efficiency. Windows Server System makes it possible.
The IP migration A wake-up call
Got ITIL? Tripwire can help you implement ITIL best practices.
Trend Micro The Fight Against Viruse Isn’t the Only Thing We’re Winning.
Securing Your Website for Business Looking for mission-critical server security?
Click for cost-effective Intel® enterprise solutions
Looking for service desk software that can save you money?
EnvoyWorldWide White Paper: 'Shattering the Myths of Automated Notifications'
Enterprise Grid Alliance Helping make grid computing work for you
Scalable. Affordable. Reliable. IBM eServer xSeries systems with Intel® XEON™ processors.
Dell has everything you need to Build a Scalable Enterprise Now.
Click here to share your thoughts on I.T. Chance to win a $50 cash
HP workstations: the power to propel innovation.
HP Workstation Solutions for Financial Experts. Learn more.
Stop Worms! Learn how view demo—NOW! Proactive endpoint security from Zone Labs.
HP digital projectors. Superior digital imaging technology. Buy now.
Enterprise Security Center: Exclusive collection of information for securing your business.
Retailers see opportunity in new technology investments Tune in to this new webcast to hear what’s in store for 2004
Copyright © 2004 Computerworld Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Computerworld Inc. is prohibited. Computerworld and Computerworld.com and the respective logos are trademarks of International Data Group Inc.